In California, laws surrounding assisted reproduction—including sperm donation and surrogacy—are relatively well-defined compared to many other states. Over the past several decades, California law has been shaped to clarify the rights, responsibilities, and obligations of all parties involved.
Yet, despite the state’s statutes, questions sometimes arise when a sperm donor, surrogate, or even an egg donor tries to assert parental rights.
In this article, we will discuss how such assertions can affect child custody proceedings, related concerns of same-sex couples, and under what unique circumstances a donor might have a legitimate path to custody.
Understanding these issues can help individuals plan, protect their families, and navigate legal proceedings if conflicts arise.
Do Sperm Donors Have Parental Rights in California?
California law presumes that a sperm donor who donates genetic material through a licensed physician or sperm bank is not a legal parent if the child is conceived by a woman who is not the donor’s spouse.
This principle, largely codified in the California Family Code, was created to encourage the use of donated reproductive material by clarifying that donors should not incur parental obligations (such as child support) nor automatically gain parental rights (such as custody or visitation).
However, legal presumptions can be challenged if the donor and recipient(s) have agreed to different terms. In some cases, the donor and the intended parents might sign documents affirming that the donor will retain certain levels of involvement, such as possible future visitation rights.
If such agreements are made, they can complicate the custody landscape. There are different types of child custody in California, and understanding these differences can help navigate such arrangements. But generally, if a sperm donation is conducted through proper medical channels and there is no agreement granting paternal status, California courts regard the intended parents—rather than the donor—as the legal parents of the child.
The intended parents in a surrogacy arrangement are deemed the legal parents.
Surrogates and Establishing Parental Rights
Surrogacy is another area with specific legal rules. In California, surrogacy arrangements are recognized by law, and properly executed surrogacy contracts are enforceable.
The intended parents in a surrogacy arrangement are deemed the legal parents, and the surrogate has no right to custody. Surrogates typically sign detailed agreements that waive their parental rights in favor of the intended parents.
Despite this, there are instances where a surrogate might challenge the agreement. California courts generally uphold the terms of a valid surrogacy agreement, similar to donors. Having thorough legal documentation from the beginning can go a long way toward preventing or resolving conflicts about custody and parental status.
Custody Conflicts in Same-Sex Couples and the Donor’s Role
Same-sex couples often rely on donors (sperm or egg) or surrogates to have children. In most circumstances, same-sex couples approach this by:
- Using Anonymous Donors: Working with a sperm or egg bank, ensuring there is no personal relationship with the donor, and that no parental rights are retained by the donor.
- Using Known Donors with Clear Contracts: If a friend or acquaintance provides genetic material, well-drafted donor agreements clarify that this individual is not a legal parent and that the intended parents will assume all rights and responsibilities.
When the proper legal framework is in place—especially if the donation is made through a licensed physician and a contract has been executed—courts in California are unlikely to grant a donor custody rights. However, complications can still surface if a known donor plays a significant role in the child’s life, developing a parent-like relationship and seeking to claim parental rights.
When evaluating such claims, the courts look at factors like cohabitation, financial support, and the nature of the relationship with the child.
For same-sex couples, ensuring legal parentage through adoption or parentage judgments (pre-birth or post-birth) can create an added layer of security against donor claims. It will also be important to consider custody when considering the challenges of a same sex divorce.
Can Sperm Donors be Liable for Child Support?
In California, sperm donors who donate through a licensed physician or sperm bank are generally not liable for child support. State law presumes that the donor is not recognized as a legal parent if the donation was made under the proper legal framework (i.e., through a licensed medical professional and accompanied by appropriate contracts).
This means the donor has neither parental rights nor obligations, including child support. However, exceptions may arise if the donor and recipient(s) agreed that the donor would act as a parent or if the donor established a parent-like relationship with the child over time, such as providing financial support or co-parenting. In these rare situations, a court might recognize the donor as having parental responsibilities—potentially including child support—based on the child’s best interests.
Protecting Against Donor Custody Claims
If you’re using a sperm donor—especially a known donor—and want to minimize the possibility of custody conflicts, there are several steps you can take in California:
Written Agreements: As soon as you decide to work with a known donor, consult an attorney to draft a detailed donor agreement. This document should state that the donor is providing genetic material voluntarily, that all parties acknowledge the intended parents will be the legal parents, and that the donor waives any claim to parental rights.
Medical Involvement: Ensure that the insemination or IVF procedure is handled by a licensed physician or recognized fertility clinic. Under California law, using a physician helps establish the presumption that the donor does not have paternal or maternal rights.
Adoption for Non-Biological Parent: In cases where only one of the couple is genetically related to the child, the other parent might also pursue a step-parent adoption or confirmatory adoption to solidify their legal status. This helps guard against any donor challenges to parental rights by ensuring both adults in the couple have formally recognized legal parent-child relationships.
Exceptional Circumstances Where a Donor May Seek Custody
Although California law typically bars donors from claiming custody, there are rare circumstances where a donor might succeed in having parental rights or custody recognized. These include:
Both Parents Die: If the child’s legal parents (the intended parents) both pass away, a known donor could potentially petition the court for custody or guardianship, especially if no other guardian is designated in the parents’ wills or if no close family members are available. In such cases, courts aim to protect the child’s best interests. If the donor has formed a bond with the child and is capable of providing a stable environment, a California court could grant him or her guardianship or custody.
Abuse or Neglect by the Intended Parents: In extreme cases where the legal parents are found to be abusive, neglectful, or severely addicted to substances, a donor who can demonstrate a substantial connection to the child (and an ability to provide a safe environment) might persuade a court to grant custody, at least temporarily.
Courts will look to the child’s best interests and whether the donor has stepped into a parental role or has a specific agreement that acknowledges an ongoing relationship. It will be essential to hire a Los Angeles child custody lawyer to win your case if custody is disputed.
Steps to Strengthen Legal Protections for Same-Sex Couples
For same-sex couples, ensuring robust legal protections is essential.
Here are some examples of what they can do:
Parentage Judgment (Pre-Birth or Post-Birth): Many same-sex couples get a “pre-birth order” establishing their parentage, especially in surrogacy cases. This order confirms that both intended parents are legal parents when the child is born, minimizing the donor’s standing to challenge parentage.
Adoption: If pre-birth judgments are not available (or if they weren’t obtained in a timely fashion), an adoption—often a step-parent or second-parent adoption—can further solidify the non-biological parent’s legal rights.
Donor Agreements: Even if you have a friendly or family relationship with the donor, formal contracts are critical to show that everyone understood the donor would not act as a parent.
***
In California, the law aims to protect intended parents in assisted reproduction arrangements, granting them full parental rights while relieving donors and surrogates of parental obligations. For same-sex couples and others who rely on donors, this legal clarity is critical for family planning.
However, it is still important to remember that unique circumstances can sometimes open doors for a donor to petition for custody.
The best defense is proactive planning: consider consulting a family law attorney to help draft ironclad contracts, and be fully informed about the law before embarking on a donor or surrogacy arrangement. Doing so minimizes the risk of future conflicts and helps safeguard the well-being of any child born into your family.
About Family Law Attorney, Leon F. Bennett, Esq.
The Law Offices of Leon F. Bennett have been providing ethical and effective Family Law services throughout Los Angeles and Ventura County for over 35 years. Our goal is to satisfy your and your family’s goals with compassion and efficiency to provide closure that honors the human elements of the process.
Whether you’re in need of a Los Angeles divorce mediation attorney or a child custody attorney in Los Angeles, Leon F. Bennett is an expert Woodland Hills divorce attorney who will get the desired results for you and your family.
Contact us today to request a consultation.
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. This content is not intended to create an attorney-client relationship. The information presented should not be construed as legal counsel or a substitute for seeking professional legal advice. Any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Leon F. Bennett Law Firm. Readers should not act or refrain from acting based on the information provided without first consulting a licensed attorney for advice specific to their individual situation.
